Monarchs gather on a "daisy tree" for nectar in the Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove. (Photo: Barry Bergman)
Monarchs gather on a “daisy tree” for nectar in the Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove. (Photo: Barry Bergman)

Humans have not been kind to animal migrations. Relentless hunting over a century ago ensured that we will never watch billions of passenger pigeons turn day to night as they pass overhead or hundreds of thousands of bison disappear in clouds of dust as they thunder across the prairie. Today, we risk losing what some consider the most spectacular journey of all – the mutigenerational migration of the monarch butterfly.

So many eastern monarchs once congregated in the Mexican forests where they spend the winter that observers likened the sound of their fluttering wings to a rippling stream. Even the much smaller western monarch population once clustered in masses dense enough to break branches on California’s coastal trees.

But over the past 20 years, both populations have declined by over 90 percent. And in a classic case of good intentions gone awry, efforts to help the beleaguered butterflies may be inadvertently making matters worse by changing their behavior.

Growing threats

Deforestation in Mexico and development along California’s coast have destroyed much of the monarch’s winter habitat. But the widespread loss of breeding habitat — which for monarchs means milkweed, the only thing their caterpillars eat — poses a much bigger threat.

In the Midwest, where half of Mexico’s overwintering monarchs are born, nearly 60 percent of native milkweeds disappeared, a 2012 study in Insect Conservation and Diversity found, coinciding with increased use of glyphosate, commonly known as Roundup, on expanded plantings of crops genetically altered to tolerate the weed killer.


 
Glyphosate is also widely used in the West. In California, it ranked among the top 10 most used pesticides in 2012 (the last year reported). Its use will likely increase as growers plant more Roundup-ready cotton and alfalfa.

When conservation groups launched campaigns to plant milkweed in gardens, along roadsides and anywhere monarchs might find it, butterfly lovers responded in droves.

“It’s amazing how many people have milkweed gardens,” says Francis X. Villablanca, a professor of biology at California Polytechnic University who studies overwintering monarchs. “Whole networks of people will go by the nursery and let all the people in the network know when the milkweed comes in.”

Overwintering monarchs populations along California's coasts declined by 90 percent since a high of 1.2 million in 1997. (Graph courtesy Xerces Society)
Overwintering monarch populations along California’s coasts have collapsed since 1997. Estimates for fall 2013 represent 50 percent of the 17-year average. (Graph courtesy Xerces Society)

But scientists fear that some of these good-hearted efforts may be doing more harm than good. That’s because not all milkweed is created equal.

Law of unintended consequences

Monarchs that migrate are the final generation of summer breeders. Those born before them have one job: reproduce. They lay about 400 eggs within a month, then die. The last generation has a job too: travel thousands of miles to overwintering sites. They’re born in a nonreproductive state to conserve energy for the flight and the five-month wait until spring returns to their breeding grounds.

Monarchs coevolved with perennial natives that emerge in spring when monarchs are ready to breed and die back in fall when it’s time to migrate. Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is not native to California and doesn’t act like its native counterpart: it’s still going strong when the natives disappear.

Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is a favorite in butterfly gardens because it's pretty and easy to grow. (Photo: Kurt Stüber via Wikimedia Commons)
Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is a favorite in butterfly gardens because it’s pretty and easy to grow. (Photo: Kurt Stüber via Wikimedia Commons)

Because it’s pretty, easy to grow and the most widely available milkweed species in commercial nurseries, it’s become the go-to plant in butterfly gardens.

But if butterflies find it out of season and start breeding, recent research shows, they’re giving an old foe – a debilitating protozoan parasite called Ophryocystis elektroscirrha (OE) – the chance to flourish.

Adults infected with OE can drop millions of spores on milkweed, which caterpillars ingest along with leaves. Mildly infected monarchs may look fine but can’t fly or reproduce well and die early. Infested larvae may fail to emerge from their chrysalis.

Work by Sonia Altizer, a disease ecologist at the University of Georgia, has shown that when generation after generation of monarchs breed on the same plants along the Gulf Coast, parasite levels can skyrocket. Continuous breeding risks losing what Altizer calls a key benefit of migration: limiting parasite numbers by allowing monarchs to escape contaminated plants.

It doesn’t help that monarchs tend to lay far more eggs on tropical milkweed — typically grown in dense clusters — thereby exposing more caterpillars. Beyond falling prey to parasites, caterpillars born in winter could freeze during a cold snap. And with females laying so many eggs, caterpillars may starve to death.

Villablanca first saw winter-breeding butterflies in California last December. “It’s very surprising to see them breeding when they should be overwintering,” he says. “They’ve done the migration, so that part has clicked in. But why they’re reproductive is not really clear.”

A monarch draws nectar from a "daisy tree" in the Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove. (Photo: Liza Gross)
A monarch draws nectar from a “daisy tree” in the Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove. (Photo: Liza Gross)

More than 90 percent of the unseasonal breeding is happening on tropical milkweed in backyard gardens, Villablanca says. He’s trying to figure out if the breeders belong to a previously undetected non-migratory population or if they’re overwintering migrants that cluster in colonies to stay warm at night and then breed during the day.

If they’re breeding year-round, disease could pose a dangerous threat to the West’s monarchs, already in serious decline. In preliminary work, Villablanca found higher OE levels in butterflies collected from tropical milkweed gardens than from those sampled at overwintering sites. He worries that monarchs could emerge from these gardens infested and then fly to overwintering sites and spread disease.

Still, the drastic declines in milkweed remain the monarch’s biggest threat and scientists are grateful that so many people want to help.

If you have tropical milkweed in your garden, help it behave like a native: cut it back during the fall and winter. Better yet, ask your local native plant society which species are native to your area.

The last thing scientists want to do is discourage monarch enthusiasts from helping the imperiled butterflies. “We have concerns but we don’t want to spook people,” Villablanca says. “We’re really trying to help them figure out what’s the right thing to do.”

What you can do to help monarchs:

  • Avoid pesticides
    Pesticides kill monarchs throughout the life cycle.

You can view overwintering monarchs at the Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove. For more information, see For the Monarch Butterfly, a Long Road Back.

 

 

Efforts to Restore Monarch Butterflies’ Milkweed Habitats May Be Doing More Harm Than Good 20 November,2014Liza Gross
  • KokoTheTalkingApe

    I didn’t quite understand this. So the non-native milkweed keeps blooming when native species have stopped, so the monarchs keep eating them and breed instead of migrating away? Why does that encourage the protozoan parasite?

    • Sarah Roney Dalton

      Because the parasite is spread by sexual contact as well as by the caterpillars ingesting them.

    • Anonymous

      The way I understand it, typically monarchs that are infected will not survive the migration. This would give the monarchs migrating back and mating in the spring a sort of fresh start, as the spore infected plants die over the winter and new plants grow. Monarchs breeding in the winter then have a chance to infect overwintering populations where close contact can allow spores to spread rapidly. On top of this, monarchs that opt for continual breeding without migration (in areas that stay warm enough year round like parts of California) suffer from the fact that one infected butterfly can produce several infected caterpillars, and those will produce more and so forth until nearly an entire population is infected. The shutting off of breeding and the resultant migration is like a refresh button that helps the healthy population of monarchs escape the infected ones. Does this help?

      • KokoTheTalkingApe

        It does, thank you!

  • Marlena Hirsch

    I think the harm done by GMO round-up ready crops and GMO corn with Bt which kills caterpillars causes the most damage to the Monarchs east of the Rocky Mountains
    .

  • Tommy Ogren

    Good article & yes, only use native species of milkweeds. Please visit: http://www.milkweedhighway.org or http://www.safegardening.org/highway.html
    and join the Milkweed Highway! Just takes a minute.

    Thanks so much,

    Tom Ogren

Author

Liza Gross

Liza Gross, an award-winning independent journalist and senior editor at the biomedical journal PLOS Biology, writes mostly about conservation and public and environmental health. She was a 2013 recipient of the NYU Reporting Award, a 2013 Dennis Hunt Health Journalism fellow and a 2015 USC Data Journalism fellow.

Read her previous contributions to QUEST, a project dedicated to exploring the Science of Sustainability.

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor