upper waypoint

Did Smokey give us the whole story?

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Restoration burn at Dunham Elementary School, Petaluma.

A little over a month ago, my partner and I were driving home one evening when, off in the distance, we spotted a huge column of smoke rising into the sky. We exchanged nervous glances; it appeared to be originating from somewhere uncomfortably close to our neighborhood.

We arrived home to find our apartment safe and sound, but from our window we had a clear view of the hill just opposite us as smoke gushed from its top. As we watched, a line of flames crested the hill and started down the nearside, headed swiftly toward the homes in its path. As daylight faded, the dancing orange flames were joined by the blinking lights of emergency vehicles evacuating neighboring streets, and then by the hum of helicopters and planes delivering water. Amazingly, the night ended with only about 35 acres burned and no houses damaged.

Like a lot of Americans, I grew up on Smokey Bear and a cultural perception of wildfires as scary, destructive, and somehow unnatural. And they can be (the fire we witnessed is believed to have been human-caused). But did Smokey give us the whole story?

In many places -- especially California -- fire has always been part of the landscape, a key player in the cycling of nutrients and the process of succession. In recent years, scientists studying fire ecology have developed a greater understanding of how many species have adapted to survive and even exploit fire disturbances, how a century of fire suppression policy may have had unintended consequences for some ecosystems, and even how fire can be used as a restoration tool.

Sponsored

Last year, I attended a restoration burn coordinated by our Students and Teachers Restoring a Watershed (STRAW) Project in a field behind Dunham Elementary School in rural Petaluma. The intentional fire, which burned a 50'x150' patch of low-growing shrubs and grasses, provided a training exercise for the local fire department while also creating an opportunity for the students to study the effects of fire on the ecosystem.

Lined up behind a role of "caution tape," we watched as the firefighters put the torches to the field. We listened to the crackle of fire moving through grass, inhaled sweet-smelling smoke as it billowed into the morning air, watched the jutting flames. It was mesmerizing. (At the same time, I had to resist the subconscious voice saying, "You are standing in a field that is on fire. Evolutionarily speaking, now is the time for flight!") As the fire burned to its conclusion, it left in its wake a patch of blackened earth, a fresh canvas for new growth and a living classroom for the students to monitor in the years to come.

Meanwhile, we'll be watching the toast-colored hillside across the way for its own first bursts of green.

Our national fire management policies have been a subject of some discussion and controversy. Share your views below.

Ann Dickinson is Communications Manager for The Bay Institute (www.bay.org), a nonprofit research, education, and advocacy organization dedicated to protecting and restoring San Francisco Bay and its watershed, "from the Sierra to the sea."

lower waypoint
next waypoint