The Recreation and Park Department Commission on Thursday voted in favor of creating a community garden on the current site of the Haight Ashbury Neighborhood Council Recycling Center. From the SF Examiner:

A Haight-Ashbury recycling center that started 36 years ago as a community activism project on an asphalt parking lot in Golden Gate Park can expect a 90-day eviction notice today. After two hours of public outcry both supporting and opposing the closure of the center next to Kezar Stadium to make way for community-garden plots and a pedestrian plaza, the Recreation and Park Commission unanimously voted in favor of the change Thursday.

The proposal to build a garden and evict the Haight Ashbury Neighborhood Council recycling center has been the subject of considerable debate if not controversy.

On November 18, Gavin Newsom wrote a letter to Rec and Park and other city officials requesting them to start the process of creating the garden, which by necessity would include the eviction of HANC. An extract:

The HANC center served an important purpose at the beginning of the recycling movement. Currently, however, the recycling tonnage collected at HANC accounts for only about one-tenth of one percent of San Francisco’s total landfull diversion. It is reasonable to expect that those dedicated recyclers that use the facility will take their material to another existing site for proper handling-whether that means bringing bottles and cans with California redemption value to to another redemption center, or using the city’s robust curbside collection program.

Well, as you can imagine, the recycling center doesn’t exactly see it that way. On Wednesday, KQED’s Cy Musiker talked with HANC Recycling Center head Ed Dunn, who claims that Newsom is targeting HANC because of its opposition to the mayor’s Sit/Lie proposal as well as to other administration initiatives. Here is the full interview with Dunn, whose father was involved in the founding of the center in 1974. Dunn recounts the history of the center and gives his rebuttal to a number of arguments for its eviction, including the charge that HANC encourages curbside scavenging by the homeless.

Listen to the full interview:
[audio:http://ww2.kqed.org/news/wp-content/uploads/sites/10/2010/12/HANCRecycling.mp3]

[ad fullwidth]

For an opposing view, Thursday’s C.W. Nevius column in the Chronicle lays it out in blunt fashion:

The arguments in favor of shutting the place seem obvious. It’s an ugly, noisy industrial plant, totally out of place in Golden Gate Park. Everyone loves recycling, but with bins in every driveway, getting in a car and driving to a center is counter-productive. It is a magnet for the down and out, some of whom use the can and bottle payout as an ATM for booze and drugs, and even raid the neighborhood bins to fill their carts. Not only has its day passed, but community gardens would be a much better use.

Even if Park and Rec had voted against the plan, the city attorney’s office had already found that the administration does not need formal commission approval to act on it.

Related material:

Facebook: HANC Recycling Center and Native Plant Nursery
Rec and Park agenda item and recommendation
Recycling transfer station to go? (Haight Ashbury Improvement Association)
Editorial: Save the HANC Recycling Center (SF Bay Guardian)

HaightHaight

Three Recent Overdose Deaths in Haight-Ashbury Prompt Discussion of Safety, Public Health Issues

Center for S.F.’s Homeless Youth Closing – Loss of ‘a Space to Just Be OK’

Two-Alarm Fire Damages Haight Street Stores

Haight Recycling Center Given 30 Days as Rec and Park Opts for Community Garden