When Wildfires Broke Out, Only Two North Bay Cal Fire Dispatchers Were on Duty

Flames consume a home as out-of-control wildfires move through the area on October 9, 2017 in Glen Ellen.

Flames consume a home as out-of-control wildfires move through the area on Oct. 9, 2017, in Glen Ellen. (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Cal Fire says its North Bay command center received more than 3,600 calls for help in the first 48 hours of what the agency has dubbed the “October Fire Siege.”

The Sonoma-Lake-Napa emergency dispatch center, one of 21 such centers throughout the state, was flooded with calls as 172 wildfires broke out across Northern California during those first two days.

When residents smelled smoke, saw flames and fled from the inferno, many of them called 911. A significant portion of those calls got forwarded to the command center in St. Helena, where only two dispatchers were working during the first few hours of the disaster, according to their supervisor, Cal Fire Division Chief Anale Burlew.

The flood of calls began around 9:45 p.m. on Oct. 8. Within the first hour, those two dispatchers — a fire captain and a communications operator — scrambled to answer more than 229 calls, Burlew said in an interview.

“It is a chaotic situation. It is an overwhelming number of phone calls,” Burlew said. “We received numerous calls for folks that were trapped in their homes, trapped trying to evacuate by downed trees, by debris in the roadway.”

The dispatchers stayed on the phone with residents who were stuck, directed firefighters to conduct rescues and sent resources to reports of fires.

“That is a tremendous number of calls for a small facility,” said Cal Fire spokeswoman Lynne Tolmachoff, a former dispatcher. “When you have that many phone calls, it’s almost virtually impossible to keep up with every one of them.”

During those initial minutes, the two dispatchers were effectively in charge of a large part of the response to what would quickly become one of the worst disasters in California history.

Under Cal Fire’s protocol, the command center supervises the response to emergencies until fire crews arrive on the scene.

State fire officials say that of the 172 blazes that started in the first two days of the siege, 18 grew into large, fast-moving wildfires fanned by wind gusts between 40 and 70 mph.

Ten of those major fires broke out in the Sonoma-Lake-Napa unit during the first six hours of the siege. In the first moments of the crisis, the two dispatchers would help kick off a massive mutual aid system that would eventually garner support from scores of fire departments around the state, the U.S. Forest Service, the California National Guard and fire agencies from other states.

Dispatchers who were off-duty rushed into the command center. But the fires they were about to coordinate a response to got in their way as well.

“One of the struggles was the road closures and the fire prohibiting our own folks from getting into work,” Burlew said.

By the next morning, the center was staffed up with a dozen dispatchers. Two dozen other Cal Fire employees from command centers around the state came in to help with deploying resources and answering questions from the public.

At the peak of the fire siege, more than 11,000 firefighters battled 21 major blazes that burned over 245,000 acres throughout Northern California. The fires destroyed 8,900 structures, forced more than 100,000 residents from their homes and killed 42 people.

Cal Fire is reviewing the phone and radio recordings, as well as transcripts of hundreds of hours of calls, as part of the investigations into the causes of the fires, according to Burlew. The agency is also scouring its data to determine whether callers who their dispatchers were in touch with died in the blazes.

“Were some of the addresses that were calling for help people that tragically did not make it?” Burlew said.

The agency is also considering making changes to its dispatch system to improve its response to the next big disaster.

Normally, one dispatcher takes calls while the other one sleeps in the center’s barracks, according to Cal Fire spokeswoman Janet Upton. But, the weekend the fires started, the two dispatchers were awake, Upton said.

“The disaster gives us an experience base to inform future decisions,” Upton said in response to a question over whether there should be more dispatchers in the center during high-fire-risk periods. “I’m confident it will be drawn upon when making staffing decisions next fall,” she said.

Increasing the number of dispatchers has not been easy for Cal Fire, according Daren Watkins, president of the Fire Marshal and Emergency Services Association (FMESA), the union that represents more than 150 Cal Fire communications operators.

“Our staffing levels need to be bolstered year-round,” Watkins said in an interview, adding that there are scores of vacant Cal Fire dispatch positions that have yet to be filled. The union and the agency have been trying to recruit more operators, Watkins said.

When Wildfires Broke Out, Only Two North Bay Cal Fire Dispatchers Were on Duty 13 November,2017Ted Goldberg

  • Aron Quiter

    Why don’t we make major emergency response automatically spill over into the lightest areas in the region, then county, then state, then OTHER STATES?? Res ponders are on call in other areas, doesn’t it make sense when there are 4,000 calls coming in that there are more than 2 people to talk to when true disaster strikes?

Author

Ted Goldberg

Ted Goldberg is the morning editor for KQED News. His beat areas include San Francisco politics, the city’s fire department and the Bay Area’s refineries.

Prior to joining KQED in 2014, Ted worked at CBS News and WCBS AM in New York and Bay City News and KCBS Radio in San Francisco. He graduated from Oberlin College in Ohio in 1998.

You can follow him at @TedrickG and reach him on email at tgoldberg@kqed.org

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor