upper waypoint

The 'Chinese Wall': How One 1870 Cartoon Looks Oddly Familiar

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Thomas Nast's cartoon from 1870 shows European immigrants, already in the United States, pulling up the ladder to stop Chinese immigration. (Mark Fiore/KQED)

After President Trump announced his executive order banning refugees and prohibiting people from seven predominantly Muslim nations from entering the United States, a faint bell went off somewhere deep in my brain. This seems kind of familiar, I thought. I know I’ve heard about this kind of thing before.

With some memory-jogging research, I focused on the Chinese Exclusion Act and the anti-Chinese violence -- such as the 1871 Chinese Massacre -- that took place right here in California.

The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 -- the first major law restricting immigration to the United States -- was largely a response to fear on the part of Americans on the West Coast, who attributed declining wages and unemployment to Chinese workers. The act halted Chinese immigration for 10 years and prohibited Chinese from becoming U.S. citizens.

Sure, I could draw a new cartoon about the parallels to Trump's executive order and his border wall, but maybe there was a cartoon drawn back in the 1800s that's still timely today. With a little more digging, I discovered a wonderful cartoon by Thomas Nast, a man often called "the father of the American political cartoon."

The cartoon shows European immigrants, already in the United States, pulling up the ladder to stop Chinese immigration. The same issue of Harper’s included a story about a shoe factory owner who brought in Chinese immigrant workers and achieved great success.

Sponsored

According to my friend Jenny Robb, curator of the Billy Ireland Cartoon Library and Museum at Ohio State University, this particular cartoon was published in Harper's Weekly in 1870.

"This cartoon might possibly be a response to the Naturalization Act of 1870, and also to residual opposition to the Burlingame Treaty of 1868, which was ratified by China in 1869 and the growing anti-Chinese sentiment in its wake," Robb says.

"According to the issue of Harper’s Weekly where this cartoon appeared, Congress was debating the naturalization bill at this time."

Mark Fiore is a Pulitzer Prize-winning political animator and cartoonist.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Why California Environmentalists Are Divided Over Plan to Change Power Utility RatesWhy Renaming Oakland's Airport Is a Big DealAllegations of Prosecutorial Bias Spark Review of Death Penalty Convictions in Alameda CountyCecil Williams, Legendary Pastor of Glide Church, Dies at 94SF Democratic Party’s Support of Unlimited Housing Could Pressure Mayoral CandidatesNurses Warn Patient Safety at Risk as AI Use Spreads in Health CareBay Area Indians Brace for India’s Pivotal 2024 Election: Here’s What to Know‘Sweeps Kill’: Bay Area Homeless Advocates Weigh in on Pivotal US Supreme Court CaseCalifornia’s Future Educators Divided on How to Teach ReadingWhen Rivers Caught Fire: A Brief History of Earth Day