upper waypoint

Trump Suggests Jail or Loss of Citizenship for Flag Burners

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Protesters burn a U.S. flag in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 20, 2005, the day of President George W. Bush's second inauguration. (Mario Tama/Getty Images)

Updated 10:40 a.m. Tuesday

WASHINGTON — President-elect Donald Trump announced via Twitter on Tuesday that anyone who burns an American flag should face unspecified "consequences," such as jail or a loss of citizenship — a move that was ruled out by the Supreme Court nearly three decades ago.

The latest pronouncement from the president-elect came early Tuesday morning:

It was not immediately clear what prompted the tweet.

Sponsored

Trump's words put him at odds with the late Justice Antonin Scalia, who was in the majority in the 1989 decision that said flag-burning is a form of speech that is protected by the First Amendment.

Trump has called Scalia, who died in February, a great judge and said he would appoint someone to fill Scalia's seat who is much like the conservative legal icon.

In 1989, Scalia signed onto an opinion written by the liberal Justice William Brennan that struck down a criminal conviction under Texas law for burning a flag during a political protest.

Asked about that vote decades later in an interview on CNN, Scalia said he would outlaw flag-burning "if I were king." But the First Amendment exists to protect "speech critical of the government. That's the main type of speech tyrants would seek to suppress," he said.

The White House echoed Tuesday that the First Amendment should prevail in such matters.

"We have a responsibility as a country" to carefully protect the rights enshrined in the Constitution, White House spokesman Josh Earnest said, adding that the burning of the U.S. flag offends most Americans, himself included.

House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy said that he does not "support or believe in the idea of people burning the American flag. I support the First Amendment." He added that Congress has no plans to take action against flag-burning.

Also on Tuesday, Rep. Sean Duffy, R-Wis., took issue with the tweet. "We want to protect those people who want to protest. ... I disagree with Mr. Trump on that," Duffy said Tuesday on CNN's "New Day".

Duffy is the chairman of the House Financial Services Committee's panel on oversight and investigations.

lower waypoint
next waypoint
Stunning Archival Photos of the 1906 Earthquake and FireCould Protesters Who Shut Down Golden Gate Bridge Be Charged With False Imprisonment?San Francisco Sues Oakland Over Plan to Change Airport NameDeath Doula Alua Arthur on How and Why to Prepare for the EndAlameda County DA Charges 3 Police Officers With Manslaughter in Death of Mario GonzalezAfter Parole, ICE Deported This Refugee Back to a Country He Never KnewDespite Progress, Black Californians Still Face Major Challenges In Closing Equality GapGaza Aid Flotilla to Include Bay Area ResidentsSF’s Equity Program Fails to Address Racial Disparities in Cannabis IndustryHow to Create Your Own ‘Garden Wonderland’