No Escape: Conversation with “Seide” Filmmaker Elnura Osmonalieva

| May 3, 2016

Don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel!

The following is a guest post from San Francisco State University film student Ryan Thompson.

While some of us may live in a progressive world where free choice is a basic human right, in her film, Seide, Elnura Osmonalieva masterfully uses visual storytelling to transport us to her home country of Kyrgyzstan to demonstrate how women around the world are often respected in the same regard as farm animals.

Seide will screen as part of Shorts 1 at the 59th San Francisco International Film Festival on May 5th at the Roxie Theater.

Kaliman Kalybek kyzy stars as Seide

Kaliman Kalybek kyzy stars as Seide

One of the things that stuck out to me during the film was the beautiful environment it was filmed in. However while it looked very nice, I’m sure there was a lot of difficulty filming. As a result, did the story change shape in anyway due to the shooting location?

I flew from New York to Kyrgyzstan in early January 2015 to shoot a short in an urban environment. However, upon arriving and meeting actors who I had cast online, I changed my mind and decided not to shoot the story. I started changing it and went location scouting. As I drove in search of locations with my DP, Chananun Chotrungroj, we saw nothing but snow and fog with silhouettes of horsemen. It looked and felt beautiful. We stopped the car. The world was filled with cotton like fog and through it came sounds of men and horses very clearly although nobody could be seen except one guy riding a horse. He quickly charged into the thick of the fog and we had to get closer to get a look of the game they were playing. A few minutes later in the car I was thinking of a snow-horse-and human story. As I had always wanted to be able to ride a horse masterfully, I started to think of a female character driven story and that is how Seide‘s story came about.

The stunning vistas of Kyrgyzstan

The stunning vistas of Kyrgyzstan

The somber tone of the short fits well as it allows the audience to understand that the story that is depicted in the short is something that is accepted and always has been the case within the Kyrgyzstan culture and there is no point in Seide fighting against her parents wishes. With that being said, what were some of the key elements you made sure to include to establish this tone throughout the short?

I wanted to use as little dialogue as possible – [the character] Seide both literally and metaphorically has no say in the decision-making. I wanted to show her despair only through her attempt to free the horse as she feels she cannot do anything to get her self out of the situation. She feels that she too, like the horse, is helpless as she has no way of escape. She, like her horse, is a hostage of her affection to her family. She cannot believe they can hurt her and she cannot just leave. So, I chose to show how and what she feels by drawing this parallel between her and the horse. I tried to shoot their close ups together to show through visuals how they are similar – we can see their eyes at the same level, strands of hair moving, their faces next to each other

Considering both you and Seide are from Kyrgyzstan, are there other similarities you two share, or did combining personalities from those that you knew back home help create Seide?

I consider myself much luckier than Seide as I had parents who did everything for me to get good education. I know many young women who are caught between tradition and modernity, culture and personal will. Neither side guarantees happiness and the answer seems to be somewhere in between. I wanted to try to search for it.

Seide must make a life changing decision.

Seide must make a life changing decision.

As someone not familiar with Kyrgyzstan, is the lifestyle depicted in the film representative of all regions within the country, or is this type of lifestyle exclusive to the more isolated regions?

The lifestyle of Seide’s family is pretty average to the rural areas of Kyrgyzstan. There are four wheel drives and smart phones, however no running water in houses and patriarchy prevails. Matriarchy somehow coexists, and very informally, but the power is only given to the elderly women as you can see in the film.

So far the film has premiered at large festivals such as Venice and Sundance. How have the reactions for the audiences you have shown it to impacted you? Have others reactions to it made you rethink your stance towards the social issues in the film or has your showing of Kyrgyzstan women’s lifestyles opened up discussion among audiences that they have never even thought of before?

The most common responses to the film have been about how beautiful and sad it is. It makes me happy to hear that. I went for a sad and beautiful film. I have received some great feedback about how the film is able to talk about so many things at once. It can be both good and bad for a short film, I guess.

Sometimes I wish the film was more articulate, but it would then affect its poetry, the sad poetry of dilemma, the drama of life.

In my next films I would like to take a further step in addressing women’s rights and hopefully help many women and girls in Kyrgyzstan who find themselves in disadvantaged situations.

Chasing the horse away in Seide

Chasing the horse away in Seide

The film clearly deals with several gender issues that are just now finally being discussed openly throughout many places in the world. What do you hope your film adds to this discussion?

The film points to the existing problems, it does not offer any solutions, except to make you feel sad and wrong about the issue. I was hoping to show to the elderly people that they can be wrong even when they are wishing well, even the best for their child.


Behind-the-scenes of Seide

Behind-the-scenes of Seide

Considering you were working on Seide while having a newborn, in what ways do you hope the social issues discussed in your film will change by the time your children are adults?

I hope that Kyrgyzstan is able to maintain a culture where elderly people are respected and cared for and in return they can respect and care for the personal choices of the younger people. I find it difficult to be on either edge of the spectrum as I see the balance in between. I like how Kyrgyz culture requires us to be loving and caring to the elderly of the family.  Having said that I also hope my children won’t come across forced marriages in the future.

Going back to school for your graduate level instruction clearly shows that you respect the knowledge that one can learn in the classroom. What was your path like to initially get into undergraduate film school and what of that knowledge have you used to build your career?

I studied journalism and political science before choosing filmmaking for my graduate studies. Film school gave me more confidence as a filmmaker after initially stripping me of it. I learned so much and felt very lucky to indulge in learning to make films at one of the world’s best films schools. I combined my interests and made documentaries before discovering a strong urge to create visually beautiful cinema.

Seide director Elnura Osmonalieva

Seide director Elnura Osmonalieva

Is there a particular memory, event, or teacher from your schooling that you hold in close regard as you continue to excel in the filmmaking world?

It is extremely difficult to point out one teacher as I was taking something from every one of my professors. Each of them gave me a valuable skill, knowledge, a lesson or a tip. Whatever I was able to achieve with my short film Seide as writer, director and producer, I learned with the help of my professors.

Watch the Seide trailer:

Elnura Osmonalieva is a Kyrgyzstan-based writer, director and producer. She is now working on her debut feature film script to complete her graduate studies at the Tisch School of the Arts at NYU.

Learn more about the film Seide:

Like the film on Facebook:

Seide will screen as part of Shorts 1 at the 59th San Francisco International Film Festival on May 5th at the Roxie Theater.

Ryan Thompson’s guest post is part of our ongoing series of film school students interviewing aspiring filmmakers.

Ryan Thompson


Ryan J. Thompson is a San Francisco based filmmaker and the creator of the film and television discussion website Celluloid Cinema.

Category: FSSnews

Tweets by @FilmSchoolShort


Film School Shorts is made possible by a grant from Maurice Kanbar, celebrating the vitality and power of the moving image, and by the members of KQED.

Film School Shorts is a production of KQED.



Series Producer
Lisa Landi

Associate Producer
Julia Shackelford

Peter Borg

Zaldy Serrano
Christina Zee White

Original Music
Written and Produced by

John Andrieni

Kevin Cooke
Marie K Lee

Social Media Specialist
Aldo Mora-Blanco

Sarah Hoffner

On Air Promotion
Bridget Louie

William Lowery
Abby Staeble

Director of TV Production
Sandy Schonning

Executive Producer
Scott Dwyer