Doctors Struggle With Unconscious Bias, Same As Police

Since the shooting death of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo. last year, the nation has been grappling with understanding how racial tension impacts law enforcement. A few medical schools are also recognizing how health care is a similar high-stakes field, where people in power make quick decisions under intense pressure. (Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/AFP/Getty Images)

Jane Lazarre was pacing the hospital waiting room. Her son Khary, 18, had just come out of surgery, but the nurses weren’t letting her in to see him.

“They told us he would be out of anesthesia in a few minutes. He never came out,” she remembers. “The minutes became an hour, the hour became two hours.”

She and her husband became more and more frightened. It was just a routine knee operation. Lazarre asked the nurses what was going on.

“They said Khary was having ‘trouble’ coming out of anesthesia,” Lazarre says.

They called the surgeon in a panic. He went to check on their son and said that Khary had come out of anesthesia violently — thrashing and flailing about. He told Lazarre that with most young people his age, there wouldn’t have been a problem. The doctors and nurses would have gently held him down.

“But with our son, since he was so quote ‘large and powerful’ they were worried he might injure the medical staff. So they had to keep sending him back under the anesthesia,” Lazarre says.

Khary was 6 feet tall. But he was slim.

“He wasn’t the giant they were describing him as,” Lazarre says.

Baby or ‘Militant Black Panther’?

She pauses. Lazarre is white. Her husband is black. She says she started learning the role race would play in her sons’ lives the day her older son, Adam, was born.

“He was a tiny little 6 pound baby. The nurses were white,” she says. “And whenever he cried, they would refer to him as the militant Black Panther.”

Lazarre says there’s no doubt in her mind that what happened with Khary and his knee surgery was because of race.

“I understood, certainly not for the first time, that my son, and my sons both, were viewed as being dangerous, being potentially frightening to people who were white,” she says, adding that it was likely the surgeon didn’t see it that way. “Like most white people, I don’t think he was conscious of it at all.”

Lazarre and her husband insisted on seeing Khary.

“And he was indeed obviously agitated, and flailing about, covering his head with his arms,” she says. “And we saw right away that he was scared, not angry or violent.”

He was scared. Lazarre and her husband leaned over and whispered in Khary’s ear: “’It’s going to be okay, you can calm down.’ And he began coming out of the anesthesia more normally.”

Lazarre wrote about this experience in her book “Beyond the Whiteness of Whiteness: Memoir of a White Mother of Black Sons.” It will be republished in a new 20th anniversary edition next year with a new preface from Lazarre. She says there’s still so much that hasn’t changed.

Disparities Persist

Even as health overall has improved in the U.S., the disparities in treatment and outcomes between white patients, and black and Latino patients, are almost as big as they were 50 years ago. A growing body of research suggests that doctors’ unconscious behaviors play a role in these statistics, and the Institute of Medicine has called for more studies looking at discrimination and prejudice.

One study found that doctors were far less likely to refer black women for advanced cardiac care than white men with identical symptoms. Other studies show that African Americans and Latino patients are often prescribed less pain medication than white patients with the same complaints.

“We know that doctors spend more time with white patients than with patients of color,” says Howard Ross, founder of management consulting firm Cook Ross.

He’s developed a new diversity training curriculum for health care professionals that focuses on the role of unconscious bias in these scenarios.

Doctors and nurses don’t mean to treat people differently, Ross says. But, just like police, they harbor stereotypes that they’re not aware they have. Everybody does.

“This is normal human behavior,” Ross says. “We can no more stop having bias than we can stop breathing.”

Unconscious biases often surface when we’re multitasking or when we’re stressed. They come up in tense situations where we don’t have time to think. Like police on the street at night who have to decide quickly if a person is reaching for a wallet, or a gun. It’s similar for doctors in the hospital.

“You’re dealing with people who are frightened, they’re reactive,” Ross says. “If you’re doing triage in the Emergency Room, for example, you don’t have time to sit back and contemplate, ‘why am I thinking about this,’ You have to instantaneously react.”

Doctors are trained to think fast, and to be confident in their decisions.

“There’s almost a trained arrogance,” Ross says.

This leads to treatments prescribed based on snap judgments, which can reveal internalized stereotypes. A doctor sees one black patient who doesn’t take his medication, perhaps because he can’t afford it. Without realizing it, the doctor starts to assume that all black  patients aren’t going to follow instructions.

“We’re taught to learn things in a way that involves pattern recognition,” says Rene Salazar, a doctor and professor at UC-San Francisco Medical School. He says he’s fallen prey to his own biases in the exam room.

“These preconceived ideas that because someone is from a certain class or a certain background that they’re going to want pain medication for a particular reason that’s not related to your pain,” he says, is one example.

Salazar did a training with Howard Ross’ firm to get a handle on his unconscious biases. Now he teaches a similar course to all new students at the medical school at UCSF, so they can catch their biases early. Learn how they do that tomorrow, in Part 2 of this story.

Doctors Struggle With Unconscious Bias, Same As Police 1 December,2015April Dembosky

  • Dan Gibbs

    My two year old son Rowan was killed at our local Children’s hospital due to bias, stereotyping and discrimination, exactly the same as described (in detail) in this investigative series of reports from NPR and KQED. I have a direct question for April Dembosky and KQED. We have contacted our local NPR station, KPBS, 6 times over the last year to highlight Rowan’s story, ask for support and raise awareness of the consequences of discrimination in healthcare for children with special needs. We have had no reply. Can you please tell me why one story is newsworthy and the other is ignored whilst they are fundamentally the same? Innate bias is clearly not just a problem in medicine and law enforcement. Rowan’s story can be found here… and here ..

  • Sadie Holly

    I know this is not equal, I can only identify in having gone to doctors who hated women. I needed Gall bladder surgery, I wanted to discuss options with doctors, the doctor did not want me to worry my pretty head, handed me the happy gall bladder sad gall bladder coloring book to answer my questions – found another doctor.don’t even start me on anesthesiologists, I have always agree to pay out of pocket for a better anesthesiologists, they can kill you for the simplest things. Was going to have knee surgery, wanted to meet the anesthesiologist before – met him and decided he was not quite right (i.e. acting weird, like drunk or high). I told the doctor if he was it, I was leaving without the surgery. They switched me with my roommates (she was getting an optional nose job). End of story, woke up in recovery way ahead of time to see they trying to resuscitate the woman who got my first anethesiologist, they could not wake her, she died. I made a good decision.

  • Richard_Pietrasz

    If the description in this story is correct, this was a serious assault on the patient, and should be prosecuted as involuntary manslaughter. The use of general anesthesia as a restraint mechanism is worse than mere malpractice.

Author

April Dembosky

April Dembosky is the health reporter for The California Report and KQED News. She covers health policy and public health, and has reported extensively on the economics of health care, the roll-out of the Affordable Care Act in California, mental health and end-of-life issues.

Her work is regularly rebroadcast on NPR and has been recognized with awards from the Society for Professional Journalists (for sports reporting), and the Association of Health Care Journalists (for a story about pediatric hospice). Her hour-long radio documentary about home funerals won the Best New Artist award from the Third Coast International Audio Festival in 2009.

April occasionally moonlights on the arts beat, covering music and dance. Her story about the first symphony orchestra at Burning Man won the award for Best Use of Sound from the Public Radio News Directors Inc.

Before joining KQED in 2013, April covered technology and Silicon Valley for The Financial Times, and freelanced for Marketplace and The New York Times. She is a graduate of the University of California at Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and Smith College.

State of Health Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor