Phoebe and Saturn. Credit: NASA/Cassini

Who’s Phoebe? That quirky blonde from Friends? The mysteriously magical nanny from that old sitcom? A bird? A plant? All that–but the one I’m talking about is the moon of Saturn, once thought to be a captured comet, and now believed by some scientists to be something much rarer: a captured planetesimal.

Phoebe: a bit more than 120 miles across—and more potato-shaped than spherical—with a surface gravity approximately 200 times weaker than Earth’s (yes, I’d weigh about one pound standing on the surface), Phoebe is not of the stature of its larger, rounder fellow moons of greater fame: Luna, Ganymede, Titan, and the rest.

We’ve known of Phoebe’s existence since 1899, when it was discovered by astronomer W. H. Pickering, and from the start Phoebe was observed to be different from Saturn’s “mainline” moons—ones organized into a common orbital plane in close alignment with Saturn’s equator, with nice, nearly circular orbits. Phoebe is too much a nonconformist for that; orbiting at a steep, rakish angle from Saturn’s equatorial plane, backwards with respect to the conformist crowd, and with great elliptical eccentricity, Phoebe is a fringe radical! And at 30 times the distance from Saturn as our Moon is from Earth, it takes Phoebe longer to orbit Saturn (1.5 years) than Earth does to round the Sun!

All of these peculiarities added up to the hypothesis that Phoebe was not an “indigenous” satellite of Saturn—one that formed with Saturn early in the ages of the solar system—but a solar system object that was captured by Saturn at some point, and since has remained in orbit. And due to its low density (little more than one and a half times as dense as water ice), Phoebe was assumed to be a former comet. Comets passing close to gas giant planets like Saturn are sometimes flung in different directions, sometimes broken up, and sometimes even crash into the planet. But they can also be captured into orbit, as probably many of Jupiter’s smaller satellites, and Mars’ brood of two, were: former asteroids from the neighboring asteroid belt.

But a comet is a bit of material—ice and rock—left over from the formation of the solar system, about 4.5 billion years ago, pristine and barely altered from its original state. Recently, NASA’s Cassini mission has suggested a different origination story for Phoebe, based on imagery and data obtained from our first up-close look at this object by the Cassini spacecraft, in 2004.

Phoebe may be a “planetesimal”—an object that formed in the young solar system, coalescing from dust and ice into a larger and larger body. Evidence suggests that Phoebe was warmed enough during its formation, and perhaps afterward by decay of radioactive materials, to have achieved a spherical shape, a differentiated rocky core and outer shell of lighter material and ices, and possibly even to have harbored liquid water—all very planet-like qualities. As well, it may have remained in this state for quite some time before cooling down and freezing.

Possibly originating in the Kuiper Belt, beyond Neptune’s orbit, Phoebe would have migrated inward and eventually been captured when passing too close to Saturn — at the same time avoiding the typical fate of planetesimals, which is to merge with a forming planet. Planetesimals, once the bread and butter of the young solar system, are the building blocks of planets.

Phoebe, then, may be a very remarkable object–a quirky, mysteriously magical moon; a vision of the early solar system that once swarmed with such objects, even before the planets themselves appeared. It’s a messenger from the past, possibly carrying within it evidence that could tell us where we came from.

Phoebe: Quirky, Mystical, Magical Moon 11 June,2013Ben Burress
  • Burressrex

    That is a very good article–and informative! I was not aware of Phoebe, except for the Black Phoebe that lives along the Feather River. Keep up the good work! [I see they are searching for that celestial object that streaked across California…and may have left meteorite debris in its wake. Selling for $20,000 a gram! What a story, and I hope to see it here, after a ton of that is found!] “The Assturdroid Rush!”

  • is the Cassini mission the one highlighted in the Cal Academy’s star show?

    • BBurress

      Possibly–but I haven’t seen that show yet so can’t say for certain.

  • hi

    it was discover in 1898


Ben Burress

Benjamin Burress has been a staff astronomer at Chabot Space & Science Center since July 1999. He graduated from Sonoma State University in 1985 with a bachelor’s degree in physics (and minor in astronomy), after which he signed on for a two-year stint in the Peace Corps, where he taught physics and mathematics in the African nation of Cameroon. From 1989-96 he served on the crew of NASA’s Kuiper Airborne Observatory at Ames Research Center in Mountain View, CA. From 1996-99, he was Head Observer at the Naval Prototype Optical Interferometer program at Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, AZ.

Read his previous contributions to QUEST, a project dedicated to exploring the Science of Sustainability.

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor