Speier Convinced Military’s ISIS Intelligence Was ‘Doctored’

Rep. Jackie Speier during a 2014 interview. (Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call-Getty Images)

Rep. Jackie Speier says she believes U.S. military intelligence reports about the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria were changed to give the impression the group was weaker than analysts had actually concluded.

“I can tell you they were doctored,” the Peninsula congresswoman said in an interview.

In September, reports emerged that senior military officials allegedly pressured some intelligence analysts with the U.S. Central Command to paint a rosier picture of the fight against ISIS.

Central Command, or CENTCOM, oversees U.S. military activities from Egypt to Kazakhstan. The region includes several countries where the American forces are actively engaged, including Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan.

When the intelligence allegations came to light, Speier, who sits on both the House Intelligence and Armed Services committees, called the apparently altered analyses “a serious breach.”

Since then, she says, she has spoken in person with one of the 50 or so analysts who came forward to claim their conclusions were changed. The congresswoman also reviewed some of the documents that were allegedly changed, she says, confirming her concerns.

“I have reason to believe that analysis was doctored in a manner that made the impression that the intelligence was a reflection of a more positive outlook in Iraq than was justified,” she said.

Speier would not identify the analyst with whom she spoke other than to say he was not from California. She also declined to specify what documents she read.

“I think this was a very serious charge that was leveled by a whistleblower within the IC (intelligence community),” Speier said. “He is someone who has been doing this job for multiple decades, and my evaluation based on interviewing him is that he is very credible.”

On Friday, House Republican leaders announced the creation of a task force to investigate allegations that senior U.S. Central Command officials manipulated intelligence. Republicans on the Intelligence, Armed Services and Appropriations committees are leading the task force, which is expected to deliver preliminary results next month, according to Jack Langer, a spokesman for Rep. Devin Nunes, chair of the Intelligence panel.

That investigation will also focus on whether the analysts’ allegations “reflect systemic problems across the intelligence enterprise in CENTCOM or any other pertinent intelligence organizations,” the chairmen of the three committees said in a statement.

Speier said she’s also concerned about a more widespread problem.

“We’ll have to take steps to make sure that the information that is shared up the chain and to the president and to the committees of jurisdiction is, in fact, the unvarnished truth,” Speier said.

The Pentagon’s inspector general launched an investigation into the allegations in September.

A CENTCOM spokesman said in a statement that Army Gen. Lloyd Austin, who heads the command, is “taking these allegations very seriously, and we welcome the independent oversight on this matter.”

Speier Convinced Military’s ISIS Intelligence Was ‘Doctored’ 14 December,2015Ted Goldberg

  • Dick_Gosinya

    OK, now that the cat’s out of the bag, what are you going to do about it Congresswoman Speier? This has cost us countless treasure and lives, when it someone going to be held accountable? Iraq was stable when President Obama was sworn in on Jan 20, 2009. His refusal to negotiate a “Status of Forces” agreement with the Iraqi government and his total pullout left a vacuum that allowed ISIS to flourish. And, during his reelection, President Obama called them the JV team. What now Representative Speier? What now?


Ted Goldberg

Ted Goldberg is the morning editor for KQED News. His beat areas include San Francisco politics, the city’s fire department and the Bay Area’s refineries.

Prior to joining KQED in 2014, Ted worked at CBS News and WCBS AM in New York and Bay City News and KCBS Radio in San Francisco. He graduated from Oberlin College in Ohio in 1998.

You can follow him at @TedrickG and reach him on email at tgoldberg@kqed.org

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor