Workers survey burned homes near the epicenter of the September 2010 gas line explosion in San Bruno. (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Workers survey burned homes near the epicenter of the September 2010 gas line explosion in San Bruno. (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Pacific Gas & Electric Co. indicated it expects to face criminal charges for its role in the September 2010 pipeline blast in San Bruno that killed eight people, injured dozens more  and destroyed 38 homes.

PG&E Corp. and its subsidiary filed a disclosure document today with the Securities and Exchange Commission saying that it is anticipating these charges. It also reported that it has been negotiating with the U.S. Attorney’s Office in an attempt to resolve the federal investigation of the blast, which occurred on the early evening of Sept. 9, 2010, and engulfed the residential Crestmoor neighborhood in flames.

Despite the ongoing discussions, PG&E said it believes the U.S. Attorney will charge that the utility’s past operating practices violated the federal Pipeline Safety Act in such areas as pipeline integrity management, recordkeeping and identification of pipeline threats.

PG&E Chairman and CEO Tony Earley, who was brought in to lead PG&E in 2011 after the San Bruno accident, said in a statement:

“San Bruno was a tragic accident that caused a great deal of pain for many people. We’re accountable for that and make no excuses. Most of all, we are deeply sorry. We have worked hard to do the right thing for victims, their families and the community, and we will continue to do so. We’ve learned the tragic lesson of San Bruno that safety must always come first. Toward this end, we’ve implemented enormous change here at PG&E. We’re working to transform this 100-plus-year-old natural gas system into the safest and most reliable in America. In support of this, we’ve committed $2.7 billion of shareholders’ money to date and we’re making excellent operational progress. We have more work to do and we intend to do it right.”

PG&E said it believes that criminal charges are not merited and that PG&E employees did not intentionally violate the federal Pipeline Safety Act.

“The company believes that, even where mistakes were made, employees were acting in good faith to provide customers with safe, reliable, affordable, clean energy,” the utility said. “The company pledged to maintain its strong focus on safety during what is expected to be a lengthy legal process.”

An August 2011 report by the National Transportation Safety Board resoundingly blamed PG&E for the blast, citing “baffling” mistakes, sloppy oversight and a “litany of failures,” including the fact that the utility didn’t shut off the gas pouring out of the broken pipeline for almost 95 minutes. The NTSB report found more than 100 violations by the company, some of them decades old.

In its statement, PG&E touted the actions the company has taken since the blast, including replacing 127 miles of pipeline, completing nine of the 12 safety recommendations made by the NTSB, installing 134 automated valves on gas transmission pipelines and opening a state-of-the-art gas control center in August 2013.

PG&E also noted that it has settled claims amounting to nearly $500 million with the victims and families of the San Bruno accident.


PG&E Expects Criminal Charges Tied to San Bruno Blast 27 March,2014Patricia Yollin


Patricia Yollin

Pat Yollin has written about lots of stuff, including organ transplants, wayward penguins at the San Francisco Zoo, the comeback of the cream puff, New York on the fifth anniversary of 9/11, a Slow Food gathering in Italy, and the microcredit movement in Northern California. Among her favorite stories: an interview with George Lucas at Skywalker Ranch that broke the story about his plan to build a cultural museum, and a pirate Trader Joe’s operation in Vancouver that prompted the grocery chain to sue — and lose. She joined KQED in 2013 and was previously a reporter and editor at the San Francisco Chronicle, the Hearst-owned San Francisco Examiner and the Hayward Daily Review.

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor