The city of San Bruno said that Pacific Gas and Electric should pay $2.25 billion in fines for the gas pipeline blast that killed eight people in September 2010.  And the staff of the California Public Utilities Commission agreed.  City officials announced their demands Monday morning outside PG&E headquarters during the utility’s annual meeting of shareholders.

“I want these shareholders to know that their management has been irresponsible for many years and that they should take that into consideration,” said San Bruno Mayor Jim Ruane.  “They are scheduled to make a billion-dollar profit this year going forward, and they’ve made well over $2 billion since the explosion.  That’s not right.”

San Bruno Mayor Jim Ruane calls for maximum fine against PG&E. (Peter Jon Shuler/KQED)
San Bruno Mayor Jim Ruane calls for maximum fine against PG&E. (Peter Jon Shuler/KQED)

Ruane said it’s going on three years since the disaster and there’s still a long way to go.

“The system has been under-maintained for many, many years,” he said.  “Under-regulated by the CPUC and the relationship is way, way too cozy and we have to stop that right now.”

In a separate announcement the CPUC’s own Safety and Enforcement Division said it is also recommending PG&E pay $2.25 billion in penalties — the largest amount ever levied by a state regulatory agency in the nation.  The division’s director, Brig. Gen. Jack Hagan, said he’s recommending the highest possible penalty against PG&E.

“There is no amount of money that will bring back the eight people who tragically lost their lives in the pipeline blast or heal the lasting wounds to the people of San Bruno,” Hagan said.  “All we can do is make sure such a tragedy does not happen again.”

The staff announcement called PG&E’s failures “reprehensible.”

In a statement, PG&E CEO Tony Earley said he understood the desire to punish the company.  But he said the demands go too far.

“I am deeply concerned that an excessive penalty, such as those proposed, could dramatically set back our efforts to do the right thing by making it harder and more costly to finance the remaining improvements that are needed in our gas system,” Earley said.

San Bruno, CPUC Staff Call for $2.25 Billion Fine for PG&E Gas Explosion 25 April,2014Peter Jon Shuler



Peter Jon Shuler

Peter is a general assignment reporter covering Northern California news for KQED’s daily radio newscasts. He reports on a wide range of stories from current court cases to San Jose city hall.

Since joining KQED in 1990, Peter has covered everything from the beginnings of the World Wide Web to the dot-com bust, from preserving Silicon Valley's open space to the preservation of historic Valley landmarks.

Peter caught the radio bug at WAUS-FM while still a student at Andrews University in his home town of Berrien Springs, MI. He did local news and hosted a classical music program. Since then, he has pursued a variety of assignments, including production work at WBAI in New York and broadcasting to the English language community of Geneva, Switzerland via Radio 74.  Email:

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor