Governor Jerry Brown Tuesday named his first 14 appointments to County Superior Courts. And the governor’s choices defy the typical judicial profile.

Today, the California judiciary is overwhelmingly male and more than 70 percent white. But Governor Brown’s first appointments in seven counties reflect an effort to change that.

More than half of his new appointees are minorities, including Raquel Marquez, who becomes the first Latina judge in Riverside County. Marquez has 20 years of experience in the County District Attorney’s office.

Traditionally governors tend to favor judicial applicants with experience as prosecutors, like Marquez. Public defenders and defense attorneys need not apply.

But six of Brown’s new appointees do have experience as defense attorneys. That includes 41-year-old Shelyna V. Brown, an African American woman who worked in the Santa Clara County Public Defenders Office since 1997. Another appointee, Michelle Williams Court in Los Angeles, worked for a time with the ACLU of Southern California. And unlike Governor Schwarzenegger, who named both Republicans and Democrats to the bench during his time in office, all but one of Brown’s Tuesday appointees are Democrats, with one who declines to state a party affiliation.

Taken together with his appointment of UC Berkeley law professor Goodwin Liu to the State Supreme Court earlier this year, Brown seems to be opening new paths to the bench. There are nearly 50 more vacancies throughout the state, so Brown will have plenty more opportunity to reshape the courts.

That may be of concern to tough-on-crime types – victims’ rights groups, law enforcement organizations, et al. They may remember Brown’s first time as Governor when his very liberal appointments to the State Supreme Court – led by Chief Justice Rose Bird – became the target of a recall campaign because of their opposition to the death penalty. In 1986 three of “Jerry’s Judges,” including Bird, were recalled by voters. It became one of Brown’s most controversial legacies, one he worked hard to reverse first as Oakland Mayor and then as Attorney General.

Brown’s crime fighting bona fides may be put to the test again next year. Ballot measures to repeal the death penalty and reform the state’s tough Three Strikes law are likely to go before voters in November.

Jerry Brown’s Judicial Appointments Reflect More Liberal Philosophy 24 January,2018Scott Shafer

  • Mvpdda

    What did you expect from Governor Moonbeam? All this proves is that elections do matter.

  • I wouldn’t expect anything less from this commie-pinko-bed-wetting socialist pig.

  • Guest

    US law is ABSOLUTELY CRAZY: In California,
    you can get lifetime imprisonment for stealing a pizza or non-violent
    drug offenses, so that prisons are overcrowded with non-violent people
    (the money should be invested in healthcare, social systems, and
    education), and in Florida, the “Stand-Your-Ground Law” allows you to
    get away with murder, just by saying you felt threatened by your
    victim.  Since the introduction of that Law, the number of killings has
    doubled. But everybody wants to have his own gun and can get it with no
    problems, and when a massacre happens, people pretend to be shocked,
    but just one week later, they have forgotten it completely and continue
    to buy–and use–guns and protest gun control. If you lose a beloved
    person–who cares? Remember,  IN THE US, A PIZZA IS MORE VALUABLE THAN A


Scott Shafer

Scott Shafer migrated to KQED in 1998 after extended stints in politics and government to host The California  Report. Now he covers those things and more as senior editor for KQED’s Politics and Government Desk. When he’s not asking questions you’ll often find him in a pool playing water polo. Find him on Twitter @scottshafer

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor