SAN FRANCISCO (AP) San Francisco’s attempt to wade into the hotly debated relationship between cell-phone use and long-term health effects was delayed for at least a week Thursday and possibly much longer.

City attorneys agreed to U.S. District Court Judge William Alsup’s request to put off implementing the new law that would require city retailers selling cell phones to hang posters, put stickers on products and hand-out brochures discussing radiation emissions and possible health effects.

The judge asked for the delay until ruling on the industry’s request for an injunction while he considers its lawsuit challenging the law. The law was to go in effect on Tuesday. Alsup said he would rule on the industry’s request for an injunction “within a week.”

San Francisco Supervisors voted 10-1 in 2010 for the first-in-the-nation law that was to go in effect on Tuesday after previous delays prompted by an industry lawsuit.

During a hearing Thursday in San Francisco federal court, the judge appeared skeptical of San Francisco’s contention that long-term cell phone use could lead to serious health problems such as tumors and cancer.

“There is no scientific proof,” Alsup told Deputy City Attorney Vince Chabria. “You can’t prove that a single person in the entire universe has gotten cancer from a cell phone.”

Chabria countered that the opposite was also true: that no scientific proof existed guaranteeing cell phones were completely safe. Chabria said the city’s posters and brochures were intended to help concerned consumers with recommendations like using a belt clip rather than putting the device in a pants pocket.

Chabria said the World Health Organization has found frequent cell phone usage could lead to cancer and recommends reducing exposure.

Alsup replied that the Federal Communications Commission has found the cell phones safe and that officials at the “FCC, not the WHO are the experts.”

The judge did not appear persuaded that cell phone usage was a threat to human health, noting that San Franciscans have been “bathed” in radio emissions from a prominent transmission tower in the city for decades with no reported health problems.

“Anything is possible,” Alsup said. “Let’s put a brochure about UFOs. If you have concerns about UFOs, here are the steps you can take.”

The judge was also concerned that a city-produce sticker discussing radiation emission doesn’t disclose the source of the information.

“This looks like it comes from Samsung,” Alsup said of the sticker.

An industry group that filed the lawsuit contends the city’s ordinance violates its free speech rights by requiring it to distribute a city opinion about radio emissions it doesn’t believe.

“The city has basically taken over the store to get out its message,” lawyer Andrew McBride said.

The city says its literature is not a warning, but is intended to be informational only.

San Francisco Cell Phone Radiation Law Delayed; Judge Equates Concerns to Those About “UFOs” 20 October,2011KQED News Staff and Wires



    *S. Florida man now being inundated with requests from around the world and from the news media and marketing organizations that are interested in his WaveShield product to protect lives*

    Kalnitsky has been telling people about the dangers of cell phone usage for years. Finally, his time has come and he is being recognized as having a product that works to reduce radiation.

    – Kalnitsky is being asked to appear on TV and radio talk shows and news interviews to explain how to protect yourself when using your cell phones to reduce the risk of cancer –


    • Today, there are an estimated five billion cell phones used around the world. The U.S. cell phone market is growing exponentially, especially among teenagers and children. Cell phones are big business. However, studies have linked major health risks from the radiation emitted by cell phones.
    • When a call comes in to your cell phone, it travels through a microwave tower. Radiation comes in through the antenna of the phone and runs through the entire phone. The greatest danger lies in the inner ear, which has the highest absorption rate of radiation in the entire body. For those people who use wired headsets and think they are safe, they are not. In fact, wired headsets and wireless headsets such as the Bluetooth, conduct as much as three times more radiation into the ear than the phone itself. Reports also show that cordless phones were of equal or even greater risk than cell phones.
    • Cell phone radiation has been in the news quite a bit lately and blamed for the illnesses and deaths of some famous people. For example, attorney Johnny Cochran died of a brain tumor right behind his ear; and his daughter swears it was caused by using a cell phone. Senator Ted Kennedy had a glyoma, one of the three tumors to which cell phone usage has been linked.
    • Perhaps the scariest reality of it all is that children are at the greatest risk for radiation exposure, since their skulls are thinner, making it easier for radiation to go deeper into the body. In fact, France has banned all advertising to children and several European countries have age restrictions for cell phone use. Interestingly enough, the United States has done nothing.
    • Even though these terrible health risks from radiation are being reported, and the evidence is mounting, the industry giants continue to claim that their products are safe. In fact, there currently is not even a law that says that cell phone manufacturers must place a warning on their packages to inform people of the potential health risks. One might see a correlation between the cell phone industry’s continual denial of the problem with that of the tobacco industry. In fact, one may say that the cell phone industry giants are starting to sound an awful lot likeBig Tobacco.
    • A little over ten years ago, South Florida resident, Shelly Kalnitsky, was watching ABC’s 20/20, when he saw a twenty minute feature story on the dangers and potential risks of cell phone usage. The news show interviewed lobbyists and wireless representatives, who all denied there was a problem. Kalnitsky was compelled to learn more about what he had just heard. He began researching the world news regarding cell phones and discovered that information abroad included studies conducted by prominent scientists, who reached very different conclusions than what is being reported in the U.S. Kalnitsky got very concerned, especially about the danger to children, misinformation about hands-free kits and a lack of independent and unbiased reporting on cell phone issues.
    • Kalnitsky was so disturbed by what he found, that he established the Cell Phone Radiation News Bureau (, a one-stop information center and source for learning more about the potential health risks from cell and cordless phones. This bureau is intended to keep the public consumer informed and to prevent future health-related problems from cell phone use.
    • As director of the Cell Phone Radition News Bureau, Kalnitsky felt that there must be something he could do to protect people from this harmful radiation.
    • The fact is ALL cell and cordless phones emit electromagnetic radiation. Studies indicate a strong connection between cell phone use and health problems. Children and teens who begin to use mobile phones before the age of 20 are at the greatest risk. However, there is a way to provide protection when using cell and cordless phone. Up until now, there was no proof that cell phones cause cancer and health problems; but the evidence coming out is now overwhelming.
    • For more information on Waveshield, go to

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor