upper waypoint

Politicizing Public Health Decisions ... Again

Save ArticleSave Article
Failed to save article

Please try again

Cartoon: a flight attendant blows into a tube on an inflatable judge holding a gavel as shocked passengers look on. Over the intercom we read, "in the event of a mask mandate, flight attendants are instructed to deploy a trump-appointed judge from Florida."

On Monday, U.S. District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle struck down the federal mandate requiring passengers to wear masks on airplanes, trains, buses and other types of public transportation, ruling that it "exceeds the CDC's statutory authority."

At this point in the pandemic, it should be no surprise that this is yet another case of politicized lawyers, judges and advocacy groups battling scientists and public health officials.

The case was brought by the Health Freedom Defense Fund, an advocacy group based in Wyoming that has been battling mask and vaccine mandates across the country.

They found a friendly judge in Mizelle, from Florida, who was appointed by Donald Trump after he lost the election in 2020.

She was narrowly confirmed by the Senate along partisan lines, even after the American Bar Association said she was unqualified for the district court because she had such limited experience practicing law.

I don't trust Mizelle or the Health Freedom Defense Fund to make public health policy ... and I plan to keep my mask on while jammed onto a plane, train or bus, thank you very much.

Sponsored

lower waypoint
next waypoint
At Least 16 People Died in California After Medics Injected Sedatives During Police EncountersPro-Palestinian Protests Sweep Bay Area College Campuses Amid Surging National MovementCalifornia Regulators Just Approved New Rule to Cap Health Care Costs. Here's How It Works9 California Counties Far From Universities Struggle to Recruit Teachers, Says ReportWomen at Troubled East Bay Prison Forced to Relocate Across the CountryLess Than 1% of Santa Clara County Contracts Go to Black and Latino Businesses, Study ShowsUS Department of Labor Hails Expanded Protections for H-2A Farmworkers in Santa RosaAs Border Debate Shifts Right, Sen. Alex Padilla Emerges as Persistent Counterforce for ImmigrantsCalifornia Law Letting Property Owners Split Lots to Build New Homes Is 'Unconstitutional,' Judge RulesInheriting a Home in California? Here's What You Need to Know