Happy Turkey When you adhere to a special diet, whether it be for medical or ethical reasons, Thanksgiving changes. A lot. This is probably the truest for vegans, who eschew the most iconic part of the traditional Thanksgiving dinner: turkey. There are countless vegan meat alternatives out there for folks celebrating their non-omnivorous lifestyle, but there is a growing faction of veg* folks who believe that if you’re really giving up noshing on other living things, eating meat analogues just feels inherently wrong.

So what’s a culinarily-savvy vegan to do when the holiday often referred to as “Turkey Day” rolls around? Those living in the Bay Area are lucky to be surrounded by some the most diverse food-centric masterminds in the country, so there’s no end to vegan options for those who aren’t interested in dressing up a processed, gluten-laden Tofurky and calling it Thanksgiving dinner. Besides, November is officially “VeganMoFo,” or the Vegan Month of Food — so if there’s any month where autumn vegan recipes are most prolific, it’s this one.

When I was vegan — back before my food allergies kicked into high gear and I learned that meat was the only thing I could actually digest without a myriad of debilitating side effects — I put a lot of thought into creating my first epically vegan Thanksgiving feast. I made vegan collard greens, Indian-spiced chickpea pancakes, stuffing decked with nuts and fruit, and one of the most drop-dead gorgeous pecan pies my friends had ever laid eyes on. So, I can tell you firsthand that turkey isn’t a requirement for a handsome Thanksgiving dinner.

One thing we can be thankful for is the fact that the Bay Area is home to a handful of vegan bakeries, where you’ll find a selection of tantalizing sweet treats to pick up if you’re not into making your own dessert. I’ve heard wonderful things about Sugar Beat Sweets’ apple pie, a cinnamon-infused creation filled with spiced apples and topped with vanilla bean buttercream and caramel. Wholesome Bakery‘s sweet potato pecan pie is up there on my Top 10 Favorite Desserts list, vegan or otherwise, while Nabolom Bakery in Berkeley offers a great selection of vegan desserts.

What about dinner? Wayward vegans sans dinner plans can bounce over to Cafe Gratitude for their annual free Thanksgiving dinner from 11am-3pm, where everything on the menu is 100% raw and free of animal products. Oh, and did I mention that the meal was on the house? Yup, you heard that right.

But in the end, Thanksgiving is all about what you make at home, for your loved ones. This vegan pumpkin pie recipe is one of my favorites, and it’s evolved over time to include pecans and cashews, with a little orange juice in the crust to give it a little something extra. My [staunchly omnivorous] family loved this pie, and you will too.

Vegan Pumpkin Pie

Nutty Vegan Pumpkin Pie

Makes: two 8-inch pies



2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour

1/2 cup chopped cashews

1 1/2 teaspoons salt

4 teaspoons sugar

1 stick of cold shortening, cut into 10 slices
3 tablespoons cold orange juice


16 ounces silken tofu

2 cups pumpkin puree
3/4 cup agave nectar

1 teaspoon vanilla

1/2 teaspoon salt

1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

1 teaspoon allspice
1/2 teaspoon mace
1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
1/2 cup pecans, coarsely chopped


1. In a food processor, grind flour, cashews, salt and sugar until coarsely ground. Add shortening one slice at a time and pulse until the mixture resembles a coarse meal. Add orange juice and pulse for another 15 seconds.

2. Divide the dough in half and smash each half into a flat disc. Cover and refrigerate for three hours. Once the dough is chilled, roll each half out into 9-inch circles and place each into an 8-inch pie pan. Refrigerate until ready to use.

1. Preheat oven to 400 F.

2. Add tofu, pumpkin, sugar, agave, vanilla, salt, cinnamon, and spices to a food processor and blend until creamy.

3. Pour filling into pie shell and sprinkle the top with pecans, pressing them into the pumpkin filling. Bake for 1 hour, or until a toothpick inserted into the middle of the pie comes out clean. Allow to cool fully before serving. Top with vegan whipped topping.

If you’re looking for more vegan recipes to help celebrate Thanksgiving, here are a handful of useful links that will inspire you to create the dinner of your dreams, a spread so grand that your omnivorous friends will look on in utter envy of your vegan-rific culinary prowess.

Thanksgiving Dinner, Vegan-Style 28 October,2015Stephanie Stiavetti

  • I’m not a vegan, but any pie with cashews in the crust is A-OK by me!

  • How great that this is a restaurant serving a vegan T-giving! The pie looks delish!

  • I’m envious of all the great options in your area! I have vegan friends in Mill Valley and will pass on this information.

  • Donna Hull

    I’m not a vegan but that pumpkin pie recipe sounds yummy.

  • Erin McWilliams

    Is that Soyatoo on top? Looks delicious!

  • sarah henry

    hey, i’ve made lentil stew for thanksgiving, to an appreciate crowd. so i say cook what you want and folks will be happy to be fed!

    my son’s never eaten turkey (by choice). this year we’re making sweet potato biscuits, a salad with fruit, nuts, and cheese, and a side of greens, maybe kale chips, or green beans with walnut parsley pesto, or shaved brussels sprouts with cranberries and blue cheese, and we’re calling that a celebratory dinner. and i think we’ll have to add this nutty vegan pumpkin pie to the mix.

    thanks for adding your voice to all the alternate ways people can enjoy the pleasures of the table on gobble, gobble day.

  • Lisa

    just in time..thank you for all your great recipes.. now i will wait for you to come out with a book!

  • Sheryl

    This pie DOES sound wonderful, vegan or not. I’ll bet that crust is delish, too, with the addition of cashews. This is a must-try. Can I used canned pumpkin? When you say pumpkin puree, I am not sure if this is what you mean.

  • Casey@Good. Food. Stories.

    Vegan or not, my favorite part of Thanksgiving are the side dishes… if I could get away without roasting a turkey, I’d happily abandon it in favor of a few extra veggie dishes at the table. And yes, cashews in the crust – sign me up!

  • MyKidsEatSquid

    The pumpkin pie spiked with orange juice sounds excellent. When it comes to Thanksgiving, for me, it’s all about the sides anyway (and dessert).

  • Kris Bordessa

    I won’t touch shortening. Could that crust be modified to use a vegan oil instead?

  • Kris, Sure – it won’t be as flaky, but you could use margarine or some other solid fat, as long as it’s cold.

  • Like many of the others, I’m not a vegan, but I’m amazed by the ingenuity of your recipes.

  • Meredith

    I love this! Thanks for posting the vegan angle. I’m not vegan but I’m open to the recipes- esp yours!

  • I have made this nutty vegan pumpkin pie on the last weekend. It was so delicous. My family also liked it. I have make use organic coconut sugar. It tastes and looks great!! Thanks for the Recipe.


Stephanie Stiavetti

Stephanie is a writer and cookbook author recovering from her former tech-startup life. On the side she’s also a media consultant, specializing in all forms of digital goodness: audio, video, print, design, and social media.

After leaving the tech world nearly a decade ago, Stephanie made a career jump to her lifetime love, writing. She currently writes for the Huffington Post, KQED’s Bay Area Bites, NPR, and other select media outlets. Her first cookbook,Melt: The Art of Macaroni and Cheese, is due out in fall 2013 on Little, Brown with coauthor Garrett McCord.

Being a recovering techy leaves an indelible mark, and everything Stephanie does is infused with her deep fascination with digital technology. She has been blogging since 1999, before blog engines even existed and a great readership consisted of a handful of friends who occasionally thought to check out your site. In 2005 she started her first food blog, which she repurposed in 2007 to become The Culinary Life.

Stephanie can be called many things: food writer, essayist, professional recipe developer, cookbook author, social media consultant, videographer, documentary maker, website developer, archivist of life. Despite all of these titles, she most commonly responds to Steph.

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor