It was October 2012 when Hurricane Sandy bore down on New York City with a ferocity not seen since Katrina barreled over the Gulf Coast barely seven years before. There was little New Yorkers, or anyone in the storm’s path, could do other than prepare themselves for the inevitable worst that is the grim consequence of extreme weather.

The American social philosopher Eric Hoffer suggested that Nature is not subject to humane concessions such as compassion or understanding, and that its only punishment is death. It’s a dark, yet accurate assessment of the climactic forces that influence all life on this planet. Yet, out of destruction often springs the unexpected, as was the experience of acclaimed photographer Hiroshi Sugimoto.

Sugimoto, who lives between New York and his native Japan, rode out Hurricane Sandy like many other New Yorkers, watching the skies and hoping for the best as the rain fell and the waters around the city rose. After the Hudson River breached its banks and flooded several neighborhoods, Sugimoto discovered that the storage unit that was supposed to protect his work could not hold back the floodwaters. Numerous artists faced the same dismal reality that their work had been lost. But rather than cast off the damaged objects, Sugimoto explored the elements that altered his prints and gave rise to an unanticipated aesthetic evolution.

Hiroshi Sugimoto: Acts of God is the latest installation of the photographer’s work at Fraenkel Gallery, and it is anchored by the breathtaking, multi-paneled piece entitled Last Supper: Acts of God(1999/2012). Measuring over 24 feet in length, the piece features a scene of wax figures representing the last meeting of Jesus Christ and his 12 Apostles, referencing numerous paintings but most notably Leonardo Da Vinci’s famed composition in the refectory of Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan. Sugimoto’s Last Supper was captured in a wax museum in Izu, Japan for the Portraits series, an ongoing project that began as a commission by the Deutsche Guggenheim in 1999 and portrays notable figures who lived before the advent of photography, and “live” again both in wax and the photographic image. Minimal illumination throughout the exhibition creates a welcomed and contemplative setting in each of the three galleries.

Hiroshi Sugimoto, The Last Supper: Acts of God detail, 1999-2012; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery
Hiroshi Sugimoto, The Last Supper: Acts of God detail, 1999-2012; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery

Last Supper consists of five panels, four presenting groups of apostles as they flank Jesus Christ at the center. The figures are life size, each bearing artificial skin, hair, and clothing that render the forms eerie and life-like. Directly referencing Leonardo’s composition, all attention is focused on Christ, yet interactions between and reactions of the apostles create micro scenes in each panel. The figures appear to cajole, rebuke, and accuse one another at the news that one among them would betray their leader, creating a dramatic tension that is offset by Christ’s gentle manner and gesture at the composition’s center.

Prior to its watery makeover, I imagine that the scene exuded competing senses of activity and serenity. In the aftermath however, with spoiled emulsion and water-born mold combining to color and warp the print surfaces, the scene finds balance between chaos and calm. Though a glaze was applied to the surface in order to arrest the spread of mold, the photograph will continue to deteriorate as time and exposure to light leave their mark. The fragile state of the panels, likened to the deterioration of Leonardo’s tempura composition, further aligns these pieces and the subject they portray.

Hiroshi Sugimoto, In Praise of Shadows, 1998; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery
Hiroshi Sugimoto, In Praise of Shadows, 1998; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery

Sugimoto’s exploration of control and chaos within nature is magnified when other photographs in the installation are considered. Selections from In Praise of Shadows (1998) and Sea of Galilee, Golan(1992) from the Seascapes series demonstrate the photographer’s sustained interest the relationship inherent to time and photographic practice. The six photographs representing In Praise of Shadows record the photographer’s work with contained fire. The flickering candle flames, captured over a lengthy exposure time, appear as bursts of light originating from a deep, unknowable darkness. Citing Japanese novelist Jun’ichiro Tanizaki’s distaste for “violent” artificial light as an unwelcome aspect of modern life, Sugimoto searches for what is ancient and most alluring about fire. Moreover, these pieces stand as a visual metaphor of impermanence, how quickly life may be lit and subsequently extinguished.

Similarly captured over the course of a long exposure, Sea of Galilee, Golan, a large composition in which sky and water blur at the horizon line, takes up another primal element a measure of both time and faith. Accompanied by a Biblical passage attributed to Matthew, water becomes a crucible in which spiritual and corporeal devotion are tested and faith is rewarded.

Hiroshi Sugimoto, Sea of Galilee, Golan, 1992; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery
Hiroshi Sugimoto, Sea of Galilee, Golan, 1992; courtesy of Fraenkel Gallery

Hiroshi Sugimoto: Acts of God raises its most lasting point when considered in totality: the “domestication” of Nature, a near singular goal that has possessed humankind throughout our time on the planet is a laughable impossibility, despite our best efforts. She will have her way, and rightly punish our hubris with disasters such as hurricanes, floods, and fires. On rare occasions, out of that devastation emerges something new and unexpected, and it is our great fortune to witness what is born of chaos.

Hiroshi Sugimoto: Acts of God runs May 1 to July 3, 2014 at Fraenkel Gallery. For more information visit

Storms & Flooding Give New Life to Photographer’s Work 10 May,2014Roula Seikaly


Roula Seikaly

Roula Seikaly is a curator and writer based in San Francisco.

Sponsored by

Become a KQED sponsor